RELAYS ON NARROWBOATS
Being new to Narrowboat Electrics (familiar with car electrics) I find
it strange that there is no mention of using relays in the circuits eg
horn, headlight or pumps etc. Any reason for this.?
The reason why relays are so common on cars
is because with the advent of "steering stalk" switches, the switches
are not large enough to carry the current required. In the old days with
stator tubes right up through the steering column we used a horn relay
because the cables up the tube (including trafficator wiring) were not
large enough to carry the horn current, especially with twin windtone
horns.
Now, ask yourself where we would mount
such a relay for boat use. If it is going to be close to the switches we
will still need cable capable of carrying the full current the length of
the boat, if you add the cost of the relay, the slightly more
complicated and thus slightly more unreliable wiring to the cost of a
low current switch, we might just as well have used a decent switch in
the first place and saved on about 4 connections. This gives a more
reliable system that is easier to fault find.
If we mount the relays close to the light
or horn we then need a single high current conductor run the full length
of the boat, plus (for each item) a low current one. This implies two
fuses or more and again more complicated wiring and fault finding, One
might just as well use suitably rated cables and switches in the first
place and do away with complications.
FWIW, I do use relays when appropriate,
but it is not appropriate (in my view) to use them for the items you
list. As an example, I want to switch my domestic water pump from both
the kitchen and the toilet compartment as per the landing light at home.
Suitable single gang, two way, switches rated at 12/24v DC are not
available and as the pump switch might be operated with the pump under
maximum load, the non-self quenching characteristic of DC current could
lead to arching and burning of switch contacts rated at AC (the only
ones easily available). In this case I use a pair of normal AC two way
light switches, but use them to control a DC rated relay that switches
the pump current.
So it is not a case of not using relays,
but of only using them when the added complications of wiring is offset
by a gain in reliability.
back to
questions |
GAUGES READ BACKWARDS
I have just purchased a 26ft nimbus with a volvo 75hp diesel engine, the
fuel gauge reads empty when full and full when empty, also the oil
pressure gauge needle goes down when the engine is revved, the previous
owner informed me after the purchase but tells me he hasn't done
anything he knows of.If these
are bi-coil gauges with three terminal on the back, I think two are
transposed.
One is a live feed, one is a negative
connection for one coil in the gauge, and the other is another
connection for another coil, but this time running to the sender unit.
(Info and diagram on
www.reading-college.ac.uk/marine )
You need to change the two coil wires
over. If you are lucky they will be marked something like - or neg and S
(for sender). As long as you do not touch the live (+) terminal I do not
think that you can do much harm.
back to
questions |
STARTING PROBLEM
I have an electrical problem with my parsons engine. I installed 2 new
batteries and the engine started after a few turns and I ran the engine
for about 15 mins stopping and starting in between. On the last occasion
I stopped the engine when I went to restart it just wouldn't turn over
and when I turned the ignition it just clicks. the clicking seems to
come from a solenoid between the ignition and the starter motor.
I think you have either loosened a terminal
or are suffering from a coincidental fault.
First tug/push/wiggle all the terminals
on the starter circuit to see if you can find any loose ones, also try
to start it and feel for any heat - indicating a bad terminal.
Make sure your battery terminals are both
clean and tight.
The thing you describe as clicking is a
starter solenoid off something like a mini or any other older car. If
you carefully bridge the two large terminal studs with an old, large,
screwdriver - be firm and positive, try to ignore the sparks - there
will be a good chance that the starter will work. If it does, change the
solenoid. Make sure you do not touch any other metal with the
screwdriver, otherwise you could have a short circuit and fire.
If bridging the terminals does not make
the starter run, I fear you may have a faulty starter, but as I do not
know the starter type (axial, co-axial, or pre-engage) I can not give
much more advice.
In the event of needing to change the
solenoid, an insulated return version may be difficult to come by. Any
modern unit will be satisfactory as long as you mount it on wood, to
insulate it from the hull, and fit a negative wire onto a mounting
bolt/screw. back to
questions |
SOLAR
POWER
We are fitting out a new narrowboat for use on the Scottish lowland
canals. We'll initially use it as a day or weekend boat but would like
to install a power system that's suitable for residential use too. The
power audit comes out around 110 Ah at 35A peak; reading your and
Adverc's websites seems to indicate a couple of 110 Ah truck batteries
will do the job if we keep them 100% charged.
We don't want to be
endlessly running the engine just to charge the domestic batteries and
there is shore power available at our regular mooring so one option
would be to use a (say) 40A charger to provide both charge and domestic
supplies while we're moored there. Security concerns say that shore
power will be disconnected when we're not on board and there'll only be
a 12V alarm system left powered-up. Assuming the bulk charging will be
done either from the mains charger or from the alternator(s) if we're
cruising, we'd like to connect a third source, e.g. solar, to provide a
float charge while the boat's unattended.
First question is: the
three charging sources seem to require separate controllers which the
Adverc website indicates might end up confusing each other. Is there
anything available to tie all these together so we can avoid this
happening, e.g a single box which can control all three raw sources or
some kind of automatic switch-over unit?
The next question is:
if this disconnects the solar panel, what happens to the energy it's
collecting, i.e. does it need some kind of 'dump' load and if so how
might we provide that?
I think you are right to consider solar
power because of the burglar alarm.
Have you considered a well specified,
mains, three stage charger that can be left on for 100% of the time you
are away?
The easiest way to control the three
sources, especially in view of your intended use, would be a great big
three way, manual, switch. However there are automated units available,
but I have no experience with them - my motto being KIS. You need to
talk to some of the marine suppliers who advertise in the magazines.
I have asked my fellow electronics
lecturers about leaving the solar panels without load, they appear to be
of the opinion that they are just like batteries,. They just stop
producing electricity because they can no longer push electrons around
the circuit against an infinite resistance. They probably get a bit
hotter because the energy is not being converted to current. I can not
confirm this view.
back to
questions
|
TWO
BATTERY SYSTEM
I have two batteries on my boat one for the engine ,one for lights and
power ,how do I connect them , I have one battery isolator that can
isolate one or two batteries or both, do I need to run the - ve on their
own or can I link the two batteries together.
It all depends how your switch is wired.
It could be wired as a charging change over switch or as a load change
over switch. There are diagrams on
www.reading-college.ac.uk/marine under electrical notes.
I do not like these switches because if
they fail to make before they break, and you switch them with the engine
running you are likely to destroy your alternator.
My preferred method is two master
switches (one engine battery and one domestic) plus a split charge relay
- see site above.
Normally the two battery negatives are
linked with heavy cable - starter cable is fine - and the positives
switched.
back to
questions |
NARROWBOAT FRIDGE
I have been reading with great interest your question and answer pages
and this has helped me enormously during my recent wiring of my 1935
narrow boat. When I first bought the boat last year it was set up to be
permanently moored and it had one starter battery, one domestic battery
and a shore line. Only the starter battery was charged from the engine
as the system was existing from the 60's and all that had been added was
an independent Domestic battery.
I use my boats for cruising
and therefore wanted the system to be less reliant on a shore line.
I have therefore
increased to 4 x 110AH leisure batteries and fitted a Phoenix Combi
inverter/charger and a split charge relay from the alternator.
Now, my question is
regarding the good old fridge. I have 240v/12v/gas fridge which is
currently only connected to the 240v. It would be far easier to wire it
to 12v rather than connect the gas which due to the positioning etc
would be a little awkward. Also I'm far more comfortable wiring than
doing gas. Obviously I don't want the fridge draining everything so I
was thinking that I might put in a dedicated battery with another split
charge relay so that it could discharge itself without affecting
everything else. Would this be a good solution or am I coming at it
sideways? Or overcomplicating things? Would this battery be up and down
too much and harm it and therefore the others when they were all
connected via the relays?
Just for interest I've
attached the wiring diagram I drew for the system. I've learnt as I went
along by asking questions and researching etc. and am really quite
pleased with what I've managed to achieve. The only other thing I am
worried about is 240v leakage which I have read about. What should I
have to ensure that the inverter in particular is safe when operating
and unlikely to electrocute anyone!
Once again I would
like to thank you for your advice I've managed to find on net. It has
been most useful and has helped someone with a mere basic knowledge now
have almost completed a project of which I am very proud.
Thank you for all that. You will now find
our
Electrical Course notes on the website.
I am almost certain that your fridge is
an Electrolux unit and that it is only supposed to use 12 volts whilst
driving to a site in the caravan. In this mode it does not need a
thermostat, so one is not fitted to the 12v heater coil.
As an absorption fridge it is not very
efficient, so draws something in the order of 6 to 8 amps the whole time
it is turned on. I think you will draw your own conclusions.
If you can not continue to run it on gas,
then practically you have two choices. Even if you run it off 240 volts,
the loading on the batteries is likely to be the same or worse, except
it should have a 240v thermostat so may only work draw current for 50%
of the time.
1. A 12v compressor fridge. This will
cost £300 plus and if its any distance from the batteries will require
getting on for £150 for the cables.
2. A domestic 240v fridge plus inverter. As you have the inverter
already I think this is the way for you to go. The only things I would
be concerned about are:
a. Can the inverter cope with the fridge starting surge (probably yes
for your inverter)
b. How high is the inverter "stand by" current when its turned on, but
the fridge is turned off.
As far as using another split charge
relay and separate battery, you really need to do the calculations to
find out how low you would discharge it. These are in the electrical
notes mentioned above. I am happily running a TV, waterpump, lights and
12v compressor fridge on a cruising boat with a 60 amp alternator and 2
x 110ah domestic batteries.
back to
questions |
ALTERNATOR PROBLEM
I have a BMC 1.5 engine with two alternators, mounted one above the
other. One of the alternators (Lucas ACR25 I think) has stopped
charging, due to a mess up on behalf of a mechanic who took my engine
out. Can you advise what alternator I can get that will be a straight
swap, as the ACR's are a bit old and hard to get now.
By far the easiest way out of your problem -
assuming it really is the alternator and not the wiring - is to get
another ACR. If yours is the one with the big plastic end cover, then I
think any ACR that looks the same should fit. (There is an issue about
machine sensed or battery sensed, but battery sensed were quiet rare).
I think they will be readily available as
exchange units from most Motor Factors or Vehicle Electrical
Specialists, but I am also sure there will be available from a car
breakers - just look for one that looks the same.
The mounting bracket at the opposite end
to the pulley has a sliding, metal, mounting bush in it for the bolt. As
long as you support the alloy bracket with a bit of tube or something,
you should be able to tap it to move it to suit your engine mounting
brackets.
back to
questions |
NARROWBOAT BATTERY CAPACITIES
I have a 60ft narrowboat
which I am just about to move onto permanently.
I currently have 5 batteries
a 110Ah heavy duty starter battery (new) and 4 x 110Ah leisure batteries
connected together for the domestic power. I also have a Victron
inverter/charger for the 240v side and a Honda 2300w petrol gennie as
back up. The engine has 2 alternators one for the starter battery and
one (I think 35amp) for the domestic battery bank. On the load side I
have the normal lights and water pumps, a microwave, an electric kettle
and a washing machine.!
My questions are,
could I reduce the domestics to 90Ah units ? & could I mix 2 x110Ah and
2 x 90Ah units together ? Is it worth getting a battery management unit
in addition to the Victron ?
The main reason is
that I think the existing batteries have been discharged a few times
below the "safe" level and are tired and secondly I have the chance to
buy some Bosch batteries at a discount price but only for a couple more
weeks. I would buy 4 the 110Ah units but cannot get the terminal
configuration to fit my battery box whereas the 90Ah units ate available
"left" or "right" handed.
1. I hope you're wrong about the domestic
alternator only being a 35 amp unit. This would be fine for an engine
battery, but not for your domestic ones.
2. The Victron is no help whilst away
from a shore line.
First you must do a power audit - details
of how on
www.reading-college.ac.uk/marine in course notes. This will
require you to calculate the amperage drawn by all your electrical
equipment and an estimate of how long you use it for per day.
Divide battery powered equipment wattages
by 12 and inverter powered equipment wattages by 10. Multiply inverter
powered equipment amperes (if given) by 20 to get amps for the power
audit.
If 30% of your battery capacity is less
figure found in the power audit either fit an advanced alternator
controller and recalculate using 48% or install higher capacity
batteries.
You then need to decide upon a "nearly
worst case" time you will run your engine for in a day - the "day could
be two days if you tie up for a couple of days in each town.
Then (and this is only a rough guide)
multiply half the alternators rated output by the time you get in the
above paragraph. If this gives a figure in amp hours that is less than
that given in the power audit, you need a larger alternator.
If the charging current after about 10
mins running is more than about 20% of the capacity of the battery bank,
fit more batteries. This will maximise battery life. 5 X 110 ah
batteries allow about 100 amp input, and as this would probably cause
problems for an ordinary V belt, this will probably not be an issue.
Only after you have done all this can you
get an answer to your questions.
It is probably not good practice to mix
battery capacities, but may well work - it all depends how much cheaper
they are - and do Bosch supply deep cycle batteries? Please do not use
engine batteries for the domestics unless they are so cheap you can
throw them after a couple of years if you need to.
If you change from 110ah to 90ah you will
be loosing 80ah capacity, which is nearly another battery. As the
batteries will only deliver about 30% of their rated capacity and you
have a lot of high current devices I could not advise changing to 90 ah.
90 Ah will be fine for the engine.
I would always advocate an advanced
alternator controller because :
1. It will charge your batteries to about 98% fully charged as opposed
to 80% with a standard regulator.
2. It will convert your (probably) machine sensed alternator to battery
sensed (if you do not understand some electrical notes should be on the
above website by the end of April).
3. The higher state of charge will minimise sulphation, although this is
less of a problem for liveaboards where the batteries are always
charging or discharging.
My notes name the make that I feel makes
the optimum product.
Sorry about the technical stuff and maths, but if you do not do it, how
can you know what you dealing with?
back to
questions |
FUSE
RATINGS
My boat is 12v electrics. The main fuse board is a domestic type "wylex"
comprising 4 fuses of the wire type and are all rated at 15 amps. I have
just had a pre-inspection of my boat for the BSS, to identify what needs
to be done to make it compliant, and the examiner has advised that the
fuse ratings of the fusebox be checked and rectified as necessary, as it
seems odd that all the fuses in place are 15 amps. He said that i should
identify what appliances are served by each fuse and check their
ratings, but I am not sure how to do this, can you help? I do know that
one of the fuses serves all the domestic lighting on board, because I
recently had to replace the fuse, but do not know what the other 3 are
for. Your advice would be gratefully appreciated.
I do not like going against a BSS inspector
- but he is wrong.
Fuses in fuse boxes protect the wiring
NOT THE APPLIANCE. If an appliance needs its own protection it will be
fitted with its own fuse like TVs, radios and inverters it will have its
own fuse.
Just because a Wylex fuse is marked 15
amps does not mean its fused at 15 amps - that depends upon the size of
fuse wire fitted - did the inspector measure this? (rhetorical
questions) The 15 amps is the maximum rating.
In a perfect world you would ensure the
fuses blew if the current flow exceeded the capacity of the cable, but
as I have no idea about the size of cables used in your boat I can not
advise, however the most likley size for much of it is 28/0.30 with a
cross section of 2 sq mm. This is rated at 17.5 amps, so this and
anything thicker will be adequately protected by your fuses.
There is a lot more to fusing than meets
the eye, especially when looking at motors and inverters. These should
all be cabled for 20% more current than stated on the label or measured
once running - they take a lot more for a split second when starting.
At present I am putting our Boater's
Electrical course notes on the website (
www.reading-college.ac.uk/marine ) and I hope to have
them on by the end of April. These should make the whole thing clearer
for you.
back to
questions |
BATTERY
USAGE
I'm the guy who had the battery charger question for you. Thanks for
running the course last weekend, really enjoyed it. Would have liked a
bit more practical but realise limitations on time. Certainly picked up
some useful info.
I have a query with
regard to a problem we have with the boat electrics which I was hoping
you might be able to suggest a way forward.
When we bought the
boat about 7/8 years ago she was already about 4 years old and fitted
with 4 x 6 volt batteries to give us a 24 volt system. I think the
batteries were original and within the first year we started having
problems with the electrics, but generally more during the winter
(fairly obvious really with lights being on more often). These 4
batteries were replaced with 2 x 12 volt 110 amp hr. ones connected in
series.
The way we use the
boat is that my in-laws go away on the boat during the summer months,
April to end September usually. When they finish cruising for the day
they will probably watch TV and have a shower in the morning and they
did not suffer the problems we had. We have the boat out at other times
of the year and usually over the Christmas period. We cruise for the day
and will have a shower in the evening. We found that when we came to
switch the TV on (a 10" CRT colour portable) it would quite often not
switch on unless I started the engine. So we then switched the TV on
before we had a shower but the found that the TV would switch off part
way through the evening especially if the water pump was run.
In trying to resolve
the problem I found a duff inverter which was drawing current even when
nothing was running off it. This has now been taken out. We have also
replaced the CRT TV with an LCD one. The TV runs from a 24 volt to 12
volt converter and I have replaced the wiring between the converter and
the TV with thicker material (as suggested by the boatyard). Last summer
we had an Adverc fitted. Despite this we still have problems when we
went cruising last September and more so over the Christmas period. We
can cruise for 5/6 or 7 hours and if we have a shower in the evening we
have problems with the TV. We still put it in before we have a shower
and part way through the evening if the water pump is run or a light is
switched on the picture goes off on the TV although the sound stays on.
If we change the channel over the picture comes back on. We have also
noticed that if we have had the lights on for most of the night, had the
TV on and also had a shower, the water pump sounds very strained in the
morning.
Here is a list of the
electrical items we have on board:
12v radio/cassette 16w/channel. (which we rarely use)
TV 12v LCD 3.2amps
saloon lights (4) 24v 20 watts
table light 24v 20 watts
water pumps (2) one is rated at 1.8 amps the other 3.5 amps is used as a
spare and is not connected.
shower pump out 24v 6.5 amps
lights over dinette, bedroom and engine room (3) 24v 21watts.
small lights over bed (2) 24v 21/6 watts.
Fluorescent lights in galley and bathroom (2 with 2 tubes in each)
F13w/w
I've not included the tunnel lamp or the horn. We run the fridge off
gas.
Do you agree with the
following calculation based on a typical 'winter days use':
| |
|
hours used |
total amps |
| TV
|
3.2 amps (not
sure about the implications of the converter) |
5 |
16.0 |
| shower pump out |
6.5 amps |
0.5 |
3.25 |
| water pump |
2 amps |
2 |
4 |
| lights |
3 amps assuming 3
lights at 1 amp each |
6 |
18 (not sure
about fluorescents) |
| |
|
total |
41.25ahr |
Does this seem
reasonable and do you think that our battery bank of 2 12v x
110amp hr batteries connected in series should cope with this ?
Were you aware that all inverters draw a
small current if left on with no load. In my view they need their own
on/off switch - depending upon model allow about 1 amp = 24 AH per day.
Now lets look at the battery question. I
assume your calculations are correct.
You now have an Adverc, so at we can
assume them being 98% charged at the beginning of the evening as long as
you have cruised enough during the day. We know that at 50% discharged
the voltage and the life of the batteries drop. We do not know how
sulphated the batteries are or how well they hold their charge,
especially as the indications are that they have been too deeply
discharged in the past.
98% - 50% = 48%.
48% of 110 AH = 52 Ah
So with good batteries, fully charged you
have just 10AH spare. With the inverter in circuit you probably had a
deficit of 14 AH, so you were discharging your batteries too deeply,
shortening their life.
I think the 24 to 12 volt converter may
be more inefficient than an inverter - how hot does it get in use. If it
warms up its drawing current itself and probably dumps it to earth - not
very efficient!
It looks to me as if your batteries are
at or very close to the end of their life (I make them about 6/7 years
old by your figures and suspect their life was up a couple of years ago,
so you have done well). Get them tested at a battery specialist (yellow
pages). I also think that you are cutting the capacity very close. If it
was a 12v volt boat I would advise putting another battery in the bank,
but two more is a bit expensive.
back to
questions |
FITTING
SHUNT AMMETER
I am a bit confused about how to connect up my new amp hour meter (from
CruzPro) to my narrowboat's electrical system. I want to measure current
into and out at the battery bank. I have read you reply to a previous
enquiry about adding a shunt ammeter, but I am still a bit lost.
It appears (http://www.cruzpro.com/vah30.html#HEADINGA)
that there are four connections to make from the meter. One goes to the
positive terminal of the battery. Two go to the high resistance circuit
of the shunt (one +ve, one -ve). So far so good. The fourth goes to a
"ground" - I assume that is "earth" - terminal on the shunt. The other
terminal on the shunt is connected to the negative terminal of the
battery. And finally the "ground" terminal of the shunt is connected to
the "ground bus". The diagram shows the "power bus" as being connected
to the battery +ve. My system does not have an earth as such, so
what do I do?
I am not surprised you are a bit confused
- given conventional split charge, boat wiring I do not think the
diagram from the manufacturer will work.
My understanding is that these gauges
require both the load current AND charging current to pass through them,
and as drawn I think that one of those will not.
Look at your battery banks. You should
see a heavy cable (often starter cable size) joining the domestic bank
negative to the engine bank negative. This is needed to allow the
charging circuit for the domestic batteries to find its way back to
alternator negative.
You should also see another heavy cable
running from domestic negative to inside the boat. This leads to some
form of "multiway"
connector inside, or close to, the fuse/circuit breaker box - this is
the negative (or ground) bus.
The above wire only carries load current,
the inter-bank cable carries the charging current.
I think this may have to be wired as
described below, but you MUST CHECK WITH THE MANUFACTURER.
Assuming the domestic master switch is in
the positive lead.
Disconnect ALL cables from the switched
side of the master switch (I think there will be two- but there may be
more).
Connect these to one side of the shunt.
Make up a heavy lead to connect the other
side of the shunt to the master switch.
Meter (F) to small shunt terminal closest
to the master switch
Meter (E) to other small terminal
(Once fitted, if the ammeter is reading
the wrong way round, reverse these wires)
Meter (A) to any suitable negative
connection point.
Meter (C) from any domestic positive
connection via a 1 amp fuse.
Meter (D) - if you want to use it - from
any fo these, tunnel light switch, ignition switch, its own switch.
Meter (G) - a voltmeter connection, to
the engine battery positive.
Meter (H) - another voltmeter connection,
to the bowthuster, winch, or fridge battery positive.
I state that it is your responsibility to
ensure that my advice is correct.
Whilst you are on the the manufacturer
you might ask them how the meter allows for internal, self discharge of
the battery. I am not too worried about this if you are an inland
boater, but if you go to sea, you need to ensure that the meter has/can
take account of self discharge, otherwise it will be telling you that
your batteries are 3/4 charged, yet they may only be 1/2 charged.
back to
questions |
WHAT
SORT OF CHARGING SYSTEM DO I HAVE?
Having been referred to your web site from Canal Junction I was
wondering if you could help on the basis of your excellent advice and
assistance service you offer. I have just purchased a fairly old (1986)
and basic 60ft narrow boat. It has 2 domestic batteries and 1 starter
battery. There are three isolator switches in a white box next to the
batteries with negative leads entering the box. approximately 12" x 8".
One switch is marked domestic, one engine and one link. The boat was
described as "split charging". On purchase the owner had all three
switches turned on. What are the simple steps I should follow to
understand what charging system I have and how should the switches
normally be set.Please make
sure that you put a subject on your emails. Luckily I had a look through
my spam bin and found yours.
First of all visit the
www.TB-Training.co.uk website and study the charging system section
of the Electrical Course Notes. That should give you some idea of what
split charging systems are all about.
Without checking the boat I would say
that during normal use the engine and domestic switch should be turned
on and the link switch off.
I would expect the link switch would only
be used when the engine battery was flat and it would then form a sort
of "Jump lead" circuit so the engine started from the domestic battery.
This will not be good for the domestic batteries, but will do little
harm now and again.
Unfortunately the term "split charge
system" has no definition, so the above assumes some form of automatic
battery "linking" system when the alternator is charging - either a
split charge diode or split charge relay system. This, however may not
be so. That link switch may be the means of charge splitting, so you
need to do a test.
Set the switches as outlined above and
measure the voltage across both battery banks (expect over 12v on each).
Start the engine and give it a bit of a rev to make sure the alternator
has energised and remeasure each battery bank voltage. Both should have
risen and be virtually identical. If so you have some form of
"automatic" charge splitter in use.If not, turn the link switch on. You
should then find both banks give the same voltage reading. If this is
the case the link switch should be turned off as soon as the engine is
stopped for the day and on as soon as it is started in the morning.
Please be aware that master switches in
the negative side of the batteries may cause a fire under certain
conditions IF YOU HAVE ANY EQUIPMENT THAT REQUIRES A PERMANENT FEED -
typically a car radio, automatic bilge pump or security system. If
nothing is permanently fed I am sure it will be OK.
back to
questions |
BATTERIES LOSING CHARGE FASTER
THAN RECHARGING
I have a 57' narrow boat thats 15 years old and designed for long term
cruising. As such it has a Farymann Diesel Genset 18W430, a Victron 1500
inverter/charger and 4 x 6 volt Hawker service batteries. The main
engine / generator /bowthruster have dedicated batteries.
We are having electrical
power problems. The boat has a 240v , 24v and 12v systems with a 240 v
fridge and other 240v and 12v power points. Apart form the fridge and
seldom the TV the 240v circuit is not used much but the service
batteries are loosing their charge faster than the engine alternator can
replace the charge. The result is a dead 240v circuit and failure of the
Ebersbacher heating system.
I have been told by a
fellow boater that I should consider replacing the 6v service batteries
with 4 x 12v as the residual charge would last longer. It's also
possible that the old Hawker batteries are finished.
Questions.
Apart from a voltmeter
and hydrometer how can I check if the batteries are gone. They seem to
hold the charge must better from the landline.
1) Can I just replace the 4 x 6v batteries with 4 x 12v.
2) Do I need to consider the charge rate of the Victron inverter
/charger / Genset / Alternator
3) Do I need to uprate any fuses. I have a 16amp fuse box between the
landline / genset and the 240v circuit.
The voltmeter states a
charging rate of between 12 and 14 volts for the main engine, genset and
landline individually. I have two alternators. 1 for the engine /
batteries and 1 dedicated to the bow thruster.
This is probably just
a battery issue as I believe the Hawker 6v may be original, but if I can
increase the storage by uprating to 4 x 12v I would like to do so.
The life you get put of batteries will
very much depend upon how you use them, how you maintain them, and type.
I think the Hawker batteries are deep cycle batteries and this is why
they may be 15 years old especially if you often have a landline and
charger connected to them. If you want similar life out of any new
batteries make sure they are good quality deep cycle ones. The engine
starter, generator starter and possibly the bow thruster batteries
should be starter types.
You give no data on the amp hour capacity
of either your hawker batteries or the 12v ones the boater proposed that
you used, so I can not pass any comment upon getting a capacity increase
by changing to 12v batteries. As an exceedingly rough guide if the
batteries will fit into the same space they have a similar capacity.
more space = more capacity.
Inverters do not charge batteries - they
change low voltage dc into 220v ac. However I suspect that your inverter
may have a battery charger built in.
Of course you have to CONSIDER the
charging voltage from all charging equipment. If it is too low the
batteries will never be charged and if it is too high you will ruin your
batteries. However without far more information about rated capacity
from all charging sources, the charging current, and battery condition I
can not pass comment on you particular system. If the batteries are in a
poor state (probable internal short circuits) they will draw a high
current from whatever source and this will depress the charging voltage.
As the batteries charge up and the current falls, the voltage will
gradually rise to a little above 14 volts. As you say you do get to 14
volts I suspect your charging system is OK, but I am very worried about
the 12v reading. I would like to know the terminal voltage on each
battery first thing in the morning and also after being left in a
charged state and not used for a week. I suspect the terminal voltage
will be below 12v in both cases and if so it indicates faulty batteries.
I think you will find that the charger in
the inverter has a much more sophisticated charging process than the
engine alternator. However if you mean that when on the land line the
batteries do not go flat I am not surprised - they are being charged all
then time.
As for testing the batteries I trust the
hydrometer, but difference in reading between any two cells in a battery
of more than 0.3 (I say 0.5) sg indicates a faulty cell - do not try to
test if you have just topped the batteries up.
Other indications of a faulty cell are
coloured electrolyte, one cell needing far more topping up than the
others and one cell bubbling more than the others when on charge.
When battery cases swell it is a fair
indication that they are getting towards the end of their life.
You could fully charge the battery and
then put a known load on it and time the discharge. If the time x load
(amps) is significantly lower than the ah capacity the battery may well
be faulty.
Most reputable battery retailers now have
sophisticated electronic battery testers.
All the above is no use unless you do
your power/energy audit and charging calculations. You give me no idea
indication that you have done them so I would suggest that before you
part with any money you go to my website and look in either set of
course notes. Both tell you how to calculate your theoretical battery
and charging system needs - then you will start working from knowledge,
rather than towpath expertise. While there look in the electrical notes
and find out how to calculate the total battery capacity for batteries
connected in series (like each pair of your six volts) and in parallel
(like the two 6v pairs.
There is little point in increasing the
storage capacity of your battery bank unless you find it marginal or
deficient. If we are talking Hawker batteries to do so is likely to be
expensive, but as long as the charging systems you employ can cover your
discharges with up to 40% spare you will do no harm.
Be careful about changing batteries
because it is all too easy to get batteries you can not lift easily.
This may well be why you have 4 six volt ones rather than two 12 volt
ones.
You can replace the 4 x 6v batteries for
12v ones as long as you get the connections right. However I suspect you
may not get the results you think you will.
I have no idea what causes you to ask
about fusing the mains circuit because it should have little to do with
batteries and charging. If you only have a fuse on the mains circuit I
must advise that you fit a suitable RCD PDQ and also make sure the mains
system is earthed as per the BMEA codes. Fuses protect cables - nothing
else, so if your mains wiring is rated at above 16 amps then you can
increase the rating if you wish, but I still do not understand how this
fits in with the rest of the question. 16 amps at 220 volts = 3500
watts. 3500 watts at 12v = nearly 300 amps so if you are concerned that
the fuse is "throttling" the charging you need not worry. I doubt the
charger draws much more than abut 5 amps from the mains and probably
closer to 3.
If you want more help come back, but I do
need to see your energy\power audit, battery capacity and charging time
figures.
back to
questions |
12 VOLTS ON HULL
I have recently discovered that I have 12 volts flowing through the hull
of a 40 ft narrow boat, even when the isolator is turned off, which has
caused bad pitting. The isolator is on the negative I believe (although
not 100% sure). Where is this 12v likely to be coming from and is it
worth putting another isolator on the other side?
First of all how did you measure this? If
you measured between battery negative and the hull with the master
switch off you would find a voltage because the electricity from any
permanent feed equipment could not get back to the battery through the
open master switch.
I really need a complete wiring diagram
of your boat to answer this and if you had one I suspect you would have
found the answer by now.
The most likely cause is a bit of
incompetent "add on " wiring, a car radio, bilge pump or any other item
that is allowed to bypass the master switch, or wet/damp/submerged
connections.
Putting master switches in the negative
side of a boat's circuit is dangerous and can lead to fires under
certain conditions if you have any equipment with that requires a
permanent feed.
I would immediately CHANGE your master
switch(es) to the positive side.
Who said the 12v is causing the pitting?
Before it can do that it has to leave the hull and then get back into
it.
If you have a land line without an
isolation transformer or galvanic isolator that is far more likely to be
the cause.
back to
questions |
|